
I was on J-date. There I said it. I for a few months I PAID (oh the shame) for an online dating service for Jews. OY. Not only did I rarely see anyone I was even interested in most of the interest in me was well…lets just say it wasn’t worth the money.
The one date I did go on from J-date was the Jewish Chef. Although blond, which I have classically never been into, he was cute, had nice buddy holly glasses, a plaid shirt and was snarky as hell. He was smart, too smart. He over thought things. Oh did I mention he was a chef? Yah, he had me at chef.
We exchanged emails for a while. We envisioned starting a cookbook book club with French macaroons as snacks. We talked about SF style, music, friends, life and love. He kept on serving up compliments. Did I mention we talked about food? And restaurants. He was impressed with my knowledge and I was impressed there are actual normal Jewish men out there.
We decided on a hip Oakland spot he hadn’t been to yet, but I had! HA! We meet there. I remember I wore something to accentuate my bust, but it wasn’t slutty. I just figured if we were eating…
Standing in the cramped entrance I did not recognize him. He was HANDSOME. Well dressed, even stylish! POLITE. It was like hell froze over. All my online dating had literally paid me back. We sat giggled and ordered. I noticed immediately his snarky comments were almost constant. Although I pride myself of being a girl boys like to joke around with, I was almost exhausted with the pace. I thought the food was excellent like the meal I had before there. He complained about the pizza, to the waitress: eek! Well, he is a chef. It’s like trying to enjoy a library while being a librarian. Well maybe different. Anyway. It went well. We decided to see a movie. I promised if we went to a movie in SF I’d drive him back to his car in Oakland. (I know, it’s all just too perfect…)
Before the movie we stopped for ice cream, I think he got Mint Chip and I got Peach Pie. When he found out while we were buzzing around the city that I had only had my driver’s license for about 6 months, he immediately insisted he should drive MY car the rest of the night. Double-parked outside the theater, I went to hop out to grab 2 tickets and before I reached for the door handle he twisted a 20 in my hands. REALLY? Wow…that NEVER happens.
We saw Milk at the Castro Theater. We sat in our seats sipping black coffee reading San Francisco Magazine Food Issue and talked about places to go. He ran his delicious hands up and down my thighs the entire movie. HEAVEN I TELL YOU.
One of my first date moves, my patented Lizzi moves is lipstick. It gets ‘em every time. Thick, matte, serious lipstick. It’s confusing. Its like: I want that, but its messy, it’s complicated. It usually ensures I make the first kiss last till the second date. Usually.
Our first kiss was in his kitchen in the Oakland hills a few hours later, while he made me Matzo Brie. Yes ladies and gentlemen. At about 1am this man cooked me milky, salty, eggs with broken slightly mushy pieces of matzo SLATHERED with butter. It was again delicious. He kissed me with conviction. Hard. Like he wanted to say: fuck your lipstick, that shit won’t keep me away.
The next morning he asked if I wanted a drawer. In his house. For my clothes. Yes. That happened.
I woke up, drove to a nearby store and picked up coffee, bacon, eggs and some fruit. We cooked, laughed, and kissed in a bright sun filled kitchen. He even sat me up on the counter like in the movies. We laid breakfast outside in the yard and I sat on his lap in the cold early December sun and ate in the scenery and the food.
Our first date lasted the entire weekend. The only reason I had to leave aside from work was because I had scheduled another date, with a Pastry Chef. Yes. I know. What are the odds? The Jewish Chef encouraged me to keep the date just to compare the two. He joked all pastry chefs were pussies. The Pastry Chef was Russian and we did not hit it off, we did talk a lot about food and baked goods, but he just wasn’t charming. I called the Jewish Chef while I walked away from my awkward date, I told him he was the clear winner. When I got home I realized the Pastry Chef was featured in the magazine Jewish Chef and I had been reading at the Castro Theater 2 nights before. My cheeks blushed with excitement.
The only time Jewish Chef and I left his house was that first date, and once to go the movies. We brought tangerines for snacks. He was a great match, an almost perfect match, but the never left his house. That little thing was a problem. To this day he never even has been to my place.
So on New Years Eve, I brought over a feast, from New Ganges, the best Indian food in SF. I called ahead of time, told the owner how much I wanted to spend, what time I needed the food by, and explained slowly and carefully that I needed this food to make a boy fall in love with me. He said: “come at 8, for magic.” That meal was indeed magical. Thick whole-wheat chapatti with ghee everywhere. Gulab Jaman, soft golden balls of fried cheese soaked until puffy with rosewater and honey. The ascorbic Achar, pickles made from lime rinds and mango, thick with bay leaf and oil, really impressed him. Many other dishes in-between that I don’t remember. We did not fall in love.
In mid January I went to New York to see the William Eggelston Retrospective at the Whitney. I thought to myself: I am a grown woman, I can travel for art! While walking around in the January slush I visited many eating sanctuaries. I ate at the newly 3 starred Scarpetta, and had by first sweet breads, I had Blue Ribbon's classic chocolate chip bread pudding, Magnolia Bakery for cupcakes, and of course 2nd Ave deli for pastrami. I traveled with an extra bag that flight home, but not one to check: one full of 2 lbs of pastrami, 1 entire loaf of rye bread, 1 container of NY half done pickles, and 4 Magnolia cupcakes. I touched down in SF at about midnight. The drive to the Oakland hills was quick and I grinned from ear to ear the entire time. I plunked down on the Jewish Chefs couch and he slowly with huge wide eyes un-packed his presents. We ate with our fingers, with one dim lamp sitting on the floor. He said, "Man, Jewish girls really ARE better..." I felt accomplished.
The last meal the Chef and I shared was on Feb 1st. At 6am on the way to the Alameda Flea Market. We had both been excited to go and he had an entire house to furnish and a keen eye for Swedish modern antiques; it was to be an expensive but fun day. He sleepily pulled out 2 Onion Bialys from the freezer. Toasted and warm with butter, the smell dragged my butt into the dim kitchen for thick fresh ground coffee he made, a cup at a time of course. There he introduced me to heaven: Babkka. A thick doughy sweet bread, like a cinnamon chocolate sweet roll made love with Challah bread then added some streusel topping. I could NOT stay out of it. He even gave me a hard time, saying they were only made in Brooklyn, flown in and only sold at one specialty foods store in the Bay Area. He basically said hands off the Babkka. Boy was he right. After that day there were no more hands on anything.
Jewish Chef and I had incompatibilities. We were looking for different things. We could probably have gotten married and lived a very happy life together cooking for each other forever in that house. But see I am looking for a partner, a true companion, he was not into that. Me using food like a ticket into the house was no way for me to live, plus it was clear even though we had a lot in common he was not the right guy. With our inconsistencies it was clear, NO, we weren’t going to talk about it later.
I drove away knowing I would never talk to him again.